Winning or Losing an Argument

(Author, Hannah Smith, Todd Smith’s 15-Year-Old Daughter. The image is not Hannah)

Have you ever had an argument with someone important to you?  Did you win or lose?  Do you love the feeling when the opposing argument gets shut down, and your opponent conforms to your opinion? Is that your ultimate goal?  What about how your opponent feels?  Do you care?

I’m like many teenagers. Because I have strong (and often contrary) opinions, I’ve had my share of arguments; I’ve won some and lost some.

I used to not hesitate to argue. I would jump into disagreements like they were a cold pool on a summer day. I was blind to the fact that nothing good was coming from these arguments. I wasn’t changing their views. In fact, it normally made my opponents feel stronger about their own opinions, and it would cause annoyance and anger. So I began to ask myself: How can I avoid tension and successfully get my point across?

Five Solutions

Here are four things I now think about when I find myself about to enter a disagreement that could end up in a heated argument.

1.   Is it Important to Me?

Before saying anything to the other person, ask yourself: Is it worth it? What will be the benefit if I win? What will be the downside if I lose?

When I would enter an argument too quickly, I would end up not having a strong opinion or supportive facts or being unwilling to listen to my opponent, and it would start unnecessary conflict.

In one of my favorite books, How to Win Friends and Influence People, (I have to admit that my dad paid me to read it.) Dale Carnegie said: “The only way to get the best of an argument is to avoid it.” This is true, but often ignored because it takes more character to be silent than to speak one’s mind.

2.   Have a Discussion, Not an Argument

Arguments are commonly controlled by emotion, while discussions are more about understanding. It’s important not to enter a disagreement when emotionally compromised. When controlled by your emotions, you are more likely to say hurtful things, yell, and ultimately prevent the discussion from going anywhere. If you feel you are on the verge of an outburst, take a breather, and only return when you feel you are ready to approach the situation rationally.

3.   Ask Questions

Too many times I entered an argument knowing that I’m right and they’re wrong. Because why would I argue if I didn’t feel it worth fighting for? But then I realized, why would they think any different? Sometimes it is even better to ask questions rather than ignore the problem because you may begin to judge them without fully understanding their view. Simply learning why the person thinks a certain way can diminish the need for an argument all together. As my dad has taught me, there is always two sides to every story.

4.   Understand That No One Is You

No one is ever going to think the same as you. We are all very different—different personalities, different past experiences, and different present situations. Learning the way a person thinks is sometimes the only way of truly understanding their position.

Mend Old Wounds

Have you been in an argument that had no closure to it—that was just left as an open wound? It’s so important to do everything you can to find that closure. Hard feelings and grudges are often the result of unsettled conflict. Whenever my brother and I would get into an argument my parents would put us in a room and we couldn’t come out until we had worked it out. We hated it, but it worked. Finish what you started. It can be a hard thing to do, to go back to that, but re-approaching the situation with the right attitude will help it go smoother.

My Challenge

I want to encourage you to think about these four points when you find yourself on the verge of a disagreement.

What have you learned from working through difficult situations and what have you found works best in avoiding arguments?  Please share your thoughts below this post.

Simply thinking before you argue can result in less stress and more understanding, while carelessly jumping into an argument can result in regretful actions and damaged relationships.

About the Author: Hannah Smith is the daughter of Todd Smith, founder of Little Things Matter. To receive Todd’s lessons, subscribe here. All Todd’s lessons are also available on iTunes as downloadable podcasts. (Todd’s podcasts are listed #38 in America’s top 100 podcasts.)

Related Posts:

Our Lives are a Mirror Image of the Little Decisions we Make

How Likable are You?

What’s Your Brand?

Who Do I Have To Become To Get What I Want?

10 Ways To Be A Good Listener

To Earn Respect You Must Show Respect

Six Ways to Avoid Misunderstandings

The Value of Feedback and Criticism

Living Beyond Ourselves

The Power of Questions

People Are As Different As They Look

Carefully Select the People who Influence Your Life

Do You Say Things You Later Regret?

Do You Get Defensive?

I’m Sorry!

Be Open to the Ideas of Others

Don’t Try to Solve a Problem That Isn’t Yours

There Are Always Two Sides to Every Story

The Ticking Time Bomb

FREE Audio Program by Brian Tracy
  • EmailEmail
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • StumbleUponStumbleUpon
  • DiggDigg
  • Del.icio.usDelicious
  • RedditReddit
  • GoogleBuzz
  • ShareThis

  • Jennipherhau
    Great post Hannah!
    I have to keep my emotions in check constantly and it's hard to do:) Nice reminders on why it is more important to make understanding the goal instead of winning!
  • Hannah Smith
    Same here, because once I tip, its so hard to compose myself.
  • Aunt Jan
    Hannah, nice job on the information that you shared with us, so proud of you!
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Aunt Jan :)
  • Great piece Hannah. Thank you
    The apple does not fall too far from the tree.
    :-)
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Ernesto!
  • Dusi Gonzales
    Hannah, that is an EXCELLENT article! while i was reading it- i'm thinking to myself "there is NO way a kid wrote this!" very well written! GOOD JOB! now i'm going to forward it to a bunch of my loved ones... ;-)
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks you Dusi!
  • Helen Mackay
    Wow can we please hear your parenting wisdom Todd. You have a very self-aware and thoughtful daughter. Congrats Hannah on putting your view across so well. Certainly pause for thought particularly for the lawyers amongst us who love to argue!
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Helen, glad you enjoyed it.
  • DavidCookPottery
    Thank for the thoughts today. Only thing I would add is this: IF you HAVE to WIN an argument or at least the other person HAS to "lose" in some way, then you have already lost all that really matters in this world. To me. And that is compassion for the other. For their situation. For THEM. All I wanted to share.

    Thanks.
    Dave

    Dr. David A. Cook
    118 Yost Farm Rd.
    Salisbury, NC 28146
  • Uncle Barry
    Hannah,
    You make so many great points! You are so insightful. Arguments often cause people to become defensive blinding them to your point of view, leave them more convinced of their own opinion, and create walls in relationships. I like your point on seeking to understand them and their position. Covey says "Seek first to understand, then to be understood." If we first understand we might not disagree to the point of an argument. Thank you for sharing your wisdom with us all.
    Uncle Barry
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Uncle Barry. That simple quote could end so many hard feelings, cultural feuds, and prevent fights from even starting. Sometimes we get so focused on being understood, that we forget to try to understand.
  • Hi Hannah,

    You did a GREAT job on your first guest post. :-)

    I love you honey!

    Dad
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks! Love you too!
  • Larryhackman
    Great article and advice Hannah, keep up the excellent writting
  • Vickianzalone
    To Hannah ! Such wise words from one of our most promising youths of today ! Always great to get a young person's prospective !
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Vicki!
  • Lois Ingalls
    Hannah, You are fantastic. Your post is outstanding and so much knowledge to share with others and so helpful. May you be blessed above measure.
    Your proud grandma,

    Nana (Lois)
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Nana, I can't wait to see you!
  • Great job, Hannah!
  • Great job, Hannah!!
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Gerrid! Love you!
  • daniellecearbaugh
    Hi Hannah!

    You did an amazing job on your post today! I am so proud of you and you should be proud of yourself!! You are mature way beyond your years ;-).

    I LOVE YOU,

    Danielle
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Danielle, Love you too!
  • In my experience, it has always been a better practice to graciously lose arguments and then let my actions do the talking. Easy to say when I'm not in the heat of the moment. Thanks for the post!
  • Hannah Smith
    Great point. It takes so much discipline to do so, especially when emotions are involved.
  • elramirez
    Great post. You have numbered some nice solutions, being number 4 my favorite. It is really remarkable and admirable that you are putting these tips into practice yourself so early in your life. You are building a great foundation for a successful future. The best of success to you and thanks again.
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks, I'm glad you enjoyed it.
  • Hannah,

    Great job on your post! What a valuable lesson to apply to life.

    It shows that all those books that Todd paid you to read is well worth his investment. :)

    Josh
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Josh! It sure was.
  • Ruth Brown
    I feel that if we all would ask the question, What would Jesus do? It would take care of all the arguments. Ruth
  • Hey Hannah,

    Great job on your post! I have to say that Jeremy took the words right out of my mouth...you ARE wise beyond your years!

    I agree with all of your points and have to share from my personal experiences that seeking understanding before jumping to my conclusion/ opinion has been worth its wait in gold to me.

    Thanks for sharing this invaluable advice with the LTM community!

    I am proud of you and love you!
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Jessica. I love you too!
  • Hannah,

    I appreciate your lesson this morning! It was a healthy reminder and a perspective changer. You are wise beyond your years.

    Blessings,
    Jeremy
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Jeremy!
  • Donna Brewer
    Good morning Hannah, thank you for your lesson. It is very reassuring to hear one such as yourself know these values of winning or losing in their proper places. I do think the winning or losing when taken out of it's proper place, becomes the most disadvantageous. I do feel many times we as humans forget, what is the most important reason at hand that we are trying to have a solution come to. When we put things inthere proper perspective, we all win. Having this understanding at your tender age will allow you to be more aware of your actions and become a more compassionate adult. Your parents are to be commended in the way they have raised a lovely young daughter, such as yourself. Thank you, Donna Brewer
  • Hannah Smith
    Thanks Donna, I'm glad you enjoyed it.
  • Hello Hannah,
    I endorse your argument for avoiding arguments. I love a challenge and will accept yours.

    Your five solution points seem very valid to me.
    1-What is your important point? Can you make that known without conflict?
    2-Avoid adding emotions. Look for common ground. Try to become US not Us & Them.
    3-Listen first ask questions then listen again.
    4-Try to understand their perspective.
    5-Avoid having unsettled conflicts to begin with.

    Location Location Location. Always choose a pleasant place to have your discussion.

    Offer refreshments, a snack, a mint or even a stick of gum to break any tension.

    Then there is the fine art of mind programming. Being able to make your ideas seem like their ideas.

    You can also inject humor whenever possible. It is very hard to argue when both sides are laughing.

    If all else fails suck it up and apologize for being wrong in the first place. That makes you the bigger person and no #5 problem. After all, never worry about little things and it's all little things as long as you know what really matters.

    On a side note...“The worst thing about new books is that they keep us from reading the old ones." – John R. Wooden...I have a feeling this is not your problem and you are going to become one very wealthy informed teen.

    Cashing In On Knowledge,
    Kevin J. Kilroy
  • Hannah Smith
    Those are some great points Kevin. I'm glad you took the time to share.
blog comments powered by Disqus