What We Can All Learn From American Idol

One of the things I enjoy doing with my family during our designated “family time” is to watch reality television shows. While reality TV has its critics, there are lessons to be learned.

Episodes of Amazing Race, Survivor, Shark Tank, Undercover Boss and American Idol have provided opportunities for thought provoking conversation with my children. Take this past season’s Amazing Race as an example. In one of the episodes, a husband and wife team “ran their mouths” without considering the impressions they were making on the other racers.

During the very next segment of the show, a team in front of this annoyingly team “U turned” the couple. For those of you who don’t watch the show, a U turn results in an extra challenge.  Their extra challenge entailed sending and receiving a SOS message using Morse code. Too difficult for the team, they came in last place and were sent home. Does this episode ring a bell for you? Do self-control, character, likability, attitude and respect come to my mind?

American Idol has also supplied me with many lessons to share with my children and none of them have anything to do with singing. Here are three lessons with one common theme, consistently portrayed for nine straight seasons.

Present yourself with confidence

Regardless of age or experience, it is so clear who has confidence and who does not. The performers who presented themselves with confidence, looked confident, acted confident, walked with confidence, sounded confident in their interviews and belted out the songs with confidence.

The judges, from the initial auditions to the finale, stressed the importance of presenting yourself with confidence.  Getting “America’s vote” was no different. The contestants with the most confidence were the ones who received the most votes week after week.

The big take-a-way here is that people can intuitively tell if you are confident in what you are doing or saying. Being confident is one thing. Portraying it is another.

A few words of caution. There is a fine line between confidence and arrogance. Arrogant people are easy to identify. They are the ones who can’t stop telling everyone how good they are.

Start to be aware of how you present yourself through email, over the phone and in-person and consider how you can present yourself with more confidence.

Think before you speak

Making it to the top 4, contestant Michael Lynch proudly announced his goal was to make the top three. As soon as I heard his words, I told my family he was done. The judges commented on it as well and America voted him out on the very night his interview was aired.

I have noticed that each season’s top three finalists choose their words carefully. They know America is judging them by not only how well the sing and perform, but also by the things they say on camera.

Just as America is judging these contestants on what they say, the people around you are forming opinions of you based on the things you say.  Don’t allow yourself to get sloppy and say things without thinking about them first.

Accept bad news with dignity

Another common trait among the performers revealed itself during the judges’ critiques. The top performers never looked dismayed, discouraged or made excuses when critiqued by the judges. While deep down inside they may have been devastated, you couldn’t tell from their facial expressions or their verbal reactions. They understood the importance of having a “game face” and the importance of accepting constructive criticism.

Coping properly with bad news and being prepared to accept their fate became part of their personal brand. No way would America make someone the next American Idol if they whined, complained or made excuses.

As you go about your daily activities, remember that just as America is instinctively forming opinions of contestants on American Idol based on the way they present themselves, the people in your life are instinctively forming opinions of you based on how you present yourself.

If you will present yourself as a person worthy of getting America’s vote, you will win the respect and praise of those who are watching.

About the Author: Todd Smith is a successful entrepreneur of 30 years and founder of Little Things Matter. To receive Todd’s daily lessons, subscribe here. All Todd’s lessons are also available on iTunes as downloadable podcasts. (Todd’s podcasts are ranked #27 in America’s top 100 podcasts and #1 in the personal and development field.)

Related Posts:

How Likable Are You?

What’s Your Brand?

Do You Say Things You Later Regret?

The Value of Feedback and Criticism

To Earn Respect You Must Show Respect

When It’s Time To Learn, Shut Up And Listen

Is Your Attitude Helping or Hurting You? (Part 3)

Is Your Attitude Helping or Hurting You? (Part 2)

Is Your Attitude Helping or Hurting You? (Part 1)

Jim Rohn Sampler Pack
  • EmailEmail
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • StumbleUponStumbleUpon
  • DiggDigg
  • Del.icio.usDelicious
  • RedditReddit
  • GoogleBuzz
  • ShareThis

  • Great insight and analogy.

  • This is a great observation about how society works and it is worth coming back to read it again.
    Until not long ago I used to be the "poor little boy" humble, anonymous and confidence-less. End result was a very talented person (yes the world can judge me as arrogant for saying that) broke and often taken advantage of.
    Seeing that life was not going to change until I change first I embarked in a trip of self exploration and self correction.
    Self-confidence, mindful speech and taking things with dignity and emotional detachment (mentioned in post) are excellent subjects to ponder about.
    Sure all those character traits need to be adjusted with refinement not to go over board.
    Good and thought provoking post.
  • Sheri
    sorry...meant to say I do watch Idol from time to time...don't necessarily mean that one. I'm talking more about the Survivor, Bachelor, other type of shows
  • Sheri
    Love all your lessons! But have to respectfully disagree with this one to some extent. I see all the valuable teachable points you mention, but feel the damage from these shows outweighs the good. I abhor the rudeness, disrespect and lack of civility many of these reality shows encourage and reward. Not counting performance-based shows like Biggest Race, too often, the "winners" are the best political players who backstab, step over or insult fellow players as part of winning the game. I realize the world was never a perfect utopia, but do remember a time when people admired someone who was quiet, dignified and respectful of others...vs now when that's often considered wimpy and everyone seems to applaud this confrontational, ugly "in your face" type of communication.
  • Hi Sheri- Thanks for your comments. We don't watch Bachelor or Biggest Race. We do talk as a family about both people's good and bad examples and learn from them all. Have a great day!
  • donnabrewer
    Good morning Todd, thanks for another lesson. Though I don't watch American Idol, I enjoyed your analogies. I 'm a nanny for a friend, and when her six yr.old starts to whine I always sing"your a whiner fortyniner and your shoe is number nine". This gets a laugh from him and his attention, then we go from there. I've started doing this with adults when their complaining get's out of hand, I get the same response and proceed. I believe so strongly in thinking before I speak, as I've learned from past expierence having had "hoof in mouth diease". I do my best to conduct myself with as much diplomacy as possible, and try to always remember that"discretion is the better part of valor." Thank you, Donna Brewer
  • Hi Donna- Sounds like a fun song. :-) Thanks for stopping by.
blog comments powered by Disqus