The Value of Feedback and Criticism

I have made it a priority throughout my 29-year career to seek feedback from people who can help me improve on a personal and professional level. By being open to constructive criticism and people’s suggestions, I have learned a great deal.

My Experience as a Realtor

I recall a particularly helpful although humbling experience when I was a realtor in the Chicago area. After an elderly couple chose another realtor to sell their home, I called them to ask for their reason. I did this as a matter of course when people declined my services. Their feedback enlightened me. They said, “Todd, you were very professional. You had an impressive presentation and offered lots of unique services, but you did not take the time to listen to us or to show that you cared about us.”

I realized that while I offered a long list of great services, I failed at one of the basic principles of doing business: you must first build a relationship with someone before they will trust you enough to buy your product or service.

From that day forward, I never failed to gain the trust and respect of an elderly home-seller—my closing rate for elderly sellers was 100%. This is just one of the many lessons I learned by calling prospective clients who chose someone instead of me.

Seek the Advice of Experts in Your Field

Another means to obtain reliable opinions and suggestions is to seek the advice of experts in your field. I have always made this a part of my action plan in starting a new business or strategy.

In preparing to launch my blog, I learned a lot of the “little things” about how to set up and run a blog from the experts in the field. When my blog went live, I wanted to get feedback from Gary Vaynerchuk, the most recognized social media expert in the country.

As you can see from the image at the top of the post, I sat down with Gary and went through my blog with him, page by page, to determine what refinements I could make. We took it a step further and he reviewed all of my recent posts on the Little Things Matter Facebook fan page. I was receptive to any and all pearls of wisdom he could share. It was a great experience.

If one person complains, there are 100 others who feel the same way

Based on a lifetime of experiences, one of my personal beliefs is that when someone complains about something, there are 100 other people who feel the same way, but for whatever reason don’t say anything. Think about yourself…what percentage of the time do you complain or give criticism when someone has turned you off or when a business has failed to meet your expectations?

To illustrate this point, on March 3rd over a period of 15 hours, the post 10 Ways to be a Better Listener was accidentally sent three times to my newsletter subscribers. Needless to say I was upset and embarrassed because that error was a reflection on my brand. What was interesting was only one person out of every 200 subscribers said something and each of these were family members.

One of the HUGE mistakes people make when they hear feedback and criticism is they think to themselves: if only one person complained, then only one person had a bad experience. Even if it were true that only one person had a negative impression or encounter, why should you discount the feedback? If it can make you a better person or make your company better, who cares if you heard it from one person or 101 people?

Learn From Everyone Including Those Whose Feedback is Harsh

Have you ever heard people say, don’t listen to those who are overly critical or negative because you can’t make everyone happy? I agree with the principle that you can’t make everyone happy, but I also think that you should still listen to the feedback, despite the manner in which it was given.

Could it be this one person just didn’t have the personal communication skills to give their feedback with love and grace? Even if you believe their intent is to hurt you, so what? If you can grow and learn from the experience, accept it and move on.

Look For Subtle Signs of Feedback

Not only have I learned from the direct feedback I have been given but I have also learned a lot by picking up on the little things people say and do. Quite often, people won’t give you direct feedback because their inclination is to avoid a confrontation but if you listen carefully you can pick up on their true feelings by the things they say and do.

Please Give Me Your Feedback

I want each of you to know that I would really value your feedback, today, tomorrow or in the future. If you ever have any ideas or suggestions about how I can improve this blog, please tell me. I want to know because more than likely there are 100 other people who feel the same way. And if you have suggestions about how I can grow as a person, I am open to that as well.

Start to look at feedback and criticism differently. Rather than trying to run from it, seek it out; be hungry for it; because only then can you really refine what you are doing and improve. If you show your appreciation to those who take the time to offer feedback, people will become even more comfortable in helping you develop personally and professionally.

Remember, what may be logical to you may not be logical to others!

About the Author: Todd Smith is a successful entrepreneur of 30 years and founder of Little Things Matter. To receive Todd’s daily lessons, subscribe here. All Todd’s lessons are also available on iTunes as downloadable podcasts. (Todd’s podcasts are ranked #27 in America’s top 100 podcasts and #1 in the personal and development field.)

Related Posts:

What’s Your Brand?

What’s Your Value to the Market?

Becoming a Respected Leader

12 Attributes, Values and Skills of a 360-degree Leader

The Compound Effect
  • EmailEmail
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • StumbleUponStumbleUpon
  • DiggDigg
  • Del.icio.usDelicious
  • RedditReddit
  • GoogleBuzz
  • ShareThis

  • Cocoa
    Hello Todd,

    Your writings continue to serve as a priceless source of inspiration. I look forward to reading your posts on every occasion that I possibly can, as I find each one quite edifying.

    Thank you for taking the time to share! God bless you!

    Cheers,
    Cocoa
  • Hi Cocoa,

    Thanks so much for your kind words. They mean a lot.

    Glad you are enjoying my lessons.

    Cheers!

    Todd
  • Shelonda Sims
    I love your blog, little things matter. I'm an avid reader daily. Today, however, was a very pleasant variation to my normal read. I listened to the podcast...enjoyed it immensely. I hope you have your new book title on audio cassette. I will be purchasing soon. Thank you for your contribution...little things do really matter. I hoped you enjoyed my feedback!!
  • Hi Shelonda,

    Thanks for your kind message. I am glad you enjoyed the audio version.

    Yes, my new book is available on audio at www.littlethingsmatterbook.com.

    I hope you have a wonderful day.

    Todd
  • Hello Todd,
    Another great lesson to live by. Constructive criticism is a tool to advance by.

    “Failure is feedback cooking; it may not taste good until you change the recipe.”
    - K.J. Kilroy Was Here!

    Always Hungry For It,
    Kevin J. Kilroy
  • Hi Kevin,

    Thanks for your comment! Love your quote! My kids told me last night that they are enjoying all your quotes as well.

    Stay hungry!

    Todd
  • The little things really do matter, especially when it comes to building your brand. I am a witness that your brand is honest and positive. You exemplify the passion and it comes through in your communication.
    We have never met face to face but I feel that our relationship is one of purity. The sincerity comes through and the conversation is real.
    I wish I could give you some additional pointers on your blog but everything looks good to me. However, I could use a few pointers on my blog. :-) You are a great guy Todd keep doing what you are doing because it is working for you in a big way.
  • HI Donald,

    Thanks for taking your time to share such a thoughtful comment. I will go back to one of your recent emails of which I believe includes a link to your blog. I will check it out and send you an email with any suggestions I might have.

    I hope we can meet in person at some time in the future.

    Take care,

    Todd
  • donnabrewer
    Hi Todd, this new episode was very enlightening. I think that one of the hardest things we can face as human beings, is the negative critical feedback of others. However, your last thought brings it all together. That being ,that what one thinks is logical another may not. So it does behoove us to listen to what they may have to say. We will take what we feel we can improve upon and possibly think about what we may not agree with to gain some insight to a situation. Thank you, Donna Brewer
  • Hi Donna- Thanks for your comment on my feedback and criticism post. I hope you are having a great weekend.
  • Hey Todd,

    I agree with every point you made on today's post and although receiving "constructive" criticism can be difficult to hear at times, it is always worth it.

    Because so much of the work world is political I think most people shy away from offering criticism. We are afraid to step on toes and hurt feelings.

    I think how you deliver the criticism you are offering is HUGE. If people can sense that you are giving them feedback based on the fact that you care and want to see them succeed, it is much more likely that they will be appreciative and will take your comments to heart.

    I also think that we need to be proactive, as you demonstrated above, in asking for criticism and letting people know that you appreciate their comments, thoughts, suggestions, etc!

    Good stuff!

    Jessica
  • Jessica, GREAT POINT! I am going to copy and save your comment. How you give feedback to others is SO important! Thanks for contributing to today post.
  • This reminded me of high school -- I was on the speech team where I spoke for a judge whose job was to write down praise and areas to improve. At 14 and 15 years old it wasn't easy to read/incorporate/accept the criticisms -- it was much easier to say "They don't know what they're talking about." However, I quickly learned that if I could get past the initial sting and put the criticism to use, I actually had an EDGE on all the other competitors (because none of the OTHER high schoolers were learning from the criticism either). Guess what, I was nearly unbeatable. This fact is true BEYOND high school speech -- if you can discipline yourself to honestly evaluate ALL criticism with an open mind, you will have a distinctive edge over the millions who don't.
    Thanks Todd -- and I'll be sure to criticize you whenever I can. :)
  • Kindra, I LOVED your comment. I am going to copy and save it for future use. What a great story.

    Isn't your avatar photo the same one with the orange on your head? I can see you cropped off the orange. :-)

    Thanks for your contribution!

  • Yes, it is the same photo -- but I did that long before I knew of your distaste for citrus. :)
  • vickianzalone
    Hi Todd - I so agree. Sometimes it can be painful but if you really want to improve, constructive criticism is of great value. I still to this day remember a comment you made to me many moons ago that I value and remind myself of now and again. I like that you are providing more of yourself in your posts. Since I've known you for so long, I am already aware of the value you bring. I can tell you that those that I sent your video to, want more of YOU ! Your personality and genuine intent came through loud and clear ! You post em and I'll email em !
  • Hi Vicki- I always enjoy reading your positive comments. Can you ever be critical or negative? Should I ask Greg or your kids? :-)

    I will be shooting a new video sometime over the next week. Thanks for your positive comments on my video presentation.
  • vickianzalone
    p.s. looking forwardto the video !
  • Vicki- I will shoot a video for you tomorrow. It is a beautiful day on the beach today, but my daughter is playing with a friend or I would shoot it today.
  • vickianzalone
    I am sure if you asked Gregg or the boys that would shed some light for you !! I remember a statement I once heard, there's only 2 times you should give advice, if someone asks or its life or death ! Sometimes it hard to contain myself but I do my best. Really knowing who you're talking to helps too, not many can embrace the positive aspect of constructive comments. Really enjoy our "chats" !
  • Todd-

    Very nice picture. I know many that would love to have the opportunity for Gary's feedback.

    No feedback or criticism here, your blog and the content are evolving quite nicely..

    Great post!

    Shawna
  • Hi Shawna- I did not say in my post, but Gary did not have one single suggestion. He said my blog was one of the best he had ever seen. I am glad I incorporated your suggestions before showing him. It is the little things that matter in everything!

    Thanks for your help and support!
  • Todd, that is a great post. That is so humble and honest.
    I also love to ask people for feedback but I must over do it because more than once I have been told that I am insecure and hesitant by asking how others see it... Yep! balance is a fine line.
    There you go, a post on "balance" would be a great subject to address.
    Regards and thank you for your daily dedication.
  • Hi Ernesto,

    I have asked for feedback hundreds of times and I have never got the impression anyone felt I was insecure. My guess is that it is the way you are requesting the feedback or the way you are presenting yourself. If you present yourself as a confident professional seeking feedback in order to improve, you shouldn't have people think you are insecure.

    I admire the fact that you are seeking feedback. Perhaps the best feedback they have given you as that you are presenting yourself as insecure and hesitate. Being honest with yourself, do you feel you present yourself as a confident professional?

  • Good pointer, thank you. I believe I present myself in a different way depending on what the subject in discussion is. There are subjects that I feel more solid than others of course, just like anyone I guess but your suggestion goes in the right direction because I expect approval.
    Some homework to do huh?
blog comments powered by Disqus